Annals of Government shutdown: What’s up with Salmonella Heidelberg?
I’ve been trying to make sense of what’s happening with the latest horrible food poisoning outbreak: this time of antibiotic-resistant Salmonella Heidelberg. Food Safety News and attorney Bill Marler have been following the events closely.
They reported that USDA—not CDC (which was on furlough)—issued the Public Health Alert.
But the outbreak is so serious that CDC recalled staff from furlough. Now the CDC is back on the job. It reports that as of October 7:
- 278 persons in 17 states are infected with 7 outbreak strains of Salmonella Heidelberg.
- 42% of them are hospitalized (this is unusually high), and no deaths have been reported.
- 77% of cases are in California.
- The source is Foster Farms chicken
What does Foster Farms have to say about this?
First, it blames the government:
Consumers should know that as recently as Oct. 8, USDA-FSIS publicly assured the safety of our chicken: “Foster Farms chicken is safe to eat but, as with all raw chicken, consumers must use proper preparation, handling and cooking practices.” There is no recall in effect and FSIS continues to inspect our poultry on a daily basis, certifying it as Grade A wholesome.”
Then, Foster Farms argues that toxic, antibiotic-resistant salmonella are normal on poultry:
Raw poultry is not a ready-to-eat product. All raw poultry is subject to naturally occurring bacteria… According to the CDC, “It is not unusual for raw poultry from any producer to have Salmonella bacteria. CDC and USDA-FSIS recommend consumers follow food safety tips to prevent Salmonella infection from raw poultry produced by Foster Farms or any other brand.”
Bill Marler asks how come Foster Farms is not issuing a recall?
Good question. Take a look at CDC’s most recent Epi curve. Usually, these show a standard distribution pattern over time with cases rising to a peak and then declining. This one shows no sign of decline.
OK, so what, as Bill Marler asks, will it take to close Foster Farms or force it to recall its tainted products?
For starters, how about getting the government opened again. And insisting that FDA issue the final food safety rules and start enforcing them.
Update, October 11: On October 7, USDA sent three letters of intended enforcement to Foster Farms: Letter #1, Letter #2, and Letter #3. Now, according to a report from Bill Marler, the USDA has decided not to close Foster Farms or force a recall.
And here are two useful articles from Politico:
