Join NYU Libraries for an insightful discussion with some of our most esteemed panelists about how the conversation, study, and action around food has evolved over the last two decades. Together, we’ll reflect on 20 years of the Critical Topics in Food event series and examine the role that thoughtful community gatherings like these have played in shaping our collective dialogue about food. The Critical Topics in Food event series is a partnership between NYU Special Collections, NYU Steinhardt Department of Nutrition & Food Studies, and Clark Wolf.
by Marion Nestle
Aug
10
2011
Q and A: Hydroponics
Q. I would love to hear what you think about hydroponic food. My instincts tell me that organic soil is full of life and traces of nutrients and elements we don’t fully understand and here we have another frankenfood that is scientifically derived.
A. Frankenfood is too strong but I’m basically with you on this one. I don’t get hydroponics. Obviously scientists have figured out enough about plant nutrient requirements to keep them alive in water and nutrient broth but what’s the point? Soil works really well and is bound to contain substances we don’t even know about. These may even influence taste.
Chefs say even the best of hydroponic vegetables, according to a recent New York Times article, are not considered serious replacements for field-grown lettuces because they can’t reproduce the flavor.
My suspicion? People who like hydroponics don’t like getting their hands dirty (but isn’t that half the fun?).