The farm bill promotes fruits and vegetables? Really?
I was surprised to read in yesterday’s New York Times that the farm bill was full of goodies for fruits, vegetables, and organics.
While traditional commodities subsidies were cut by more than 30 percent to $23 billion over 10 years, funding for fruits and vegetables and organic programs increased by more than 50 percent over the same period, to about $3 billion.
I took a quick look at the cost accounting. Giving these program listings the benefit of the doubt:
TITLE AND PROGRAM | $ MILLIONS/10 YEARS |
SNAP | |
Assistance for community food projects | 36 |
Food insecurity nutrition incentive | 100 |
Pilot for canned, frozen fruits, vegetables | 5 |
Organic | |
Research and extension | 100 |
Specialty crop research | 745 |
Beginning farmer development | 100 |
Foundation for Food and Ag Research | 200 |
Horticulture | |
Farmers market, local food promotion | 150 |
Organic ag and tech upgrade | 10 |
Organic product promotion order | 61 |
Plant pest and disease management | 193 |
Specialty crop block grants | 270 |
Miscellaneous | |
Outreach to socially disadvantaged producers | 50 |
Even stretching the items like this, it’s $2 billion over ten years, not 3. $2 billion is good; $3 would be better.
What am I missing here?
This morning, Politico Pro Agriculture summarized what states are doing to promote local food production:
Arizona: HB 2233 would create a task force to develop recommendations for how the state can improve the quality and nutrition of food sold in state facilities, including suggestions for promoting locally grown food: http://1.usa.gov/1qniAzl
Hawaii: HB 1184 seeks to set a state-wide food sustainability standard to be achieved by 2025 that would increase the availability of locally grown and produced foods to reduce the state’s reliance on imports. The standard would be set at a level double the cash farm receipts that are produced in 2015: http://1.usa.gov/1oDB9LL
HR 82 and its senate companion SCR 6 calls on the state departments of agriculture and education to develop a farm-to-school program that would provide locally grown produce to public school salad bars: http://1.usa.gov/1h4Yq6v
SB 524 similarly seeks to create an agricultural development and food security program under an existing economic development statute that would seek to increase demand for and access to locally grow foods through promotional campaigns and improving infrastructure, among other things: http://1.usa.gov/1fiiYWP
Iowa: H2426 seeks to promote small farmers through a new financial assistance program, a marketing program, a revolving grant program and a property tax exemption for farmers who sell their products to state facilities or schools. The measure also calls for state facilities, when cost effective, to purchase from local farmers: http://bit.ly/1hYHJMg
Kansas: SB 380 aims to create a local food and farm task force to develop funding and policy recommendations for supporting and expanding local food production. The task force would be required to issue a report to the legislature by the beginning of the 2016 legislative session: http://bit.ly/1fP9Lv9
New Jersey: SR 44 calls on state and local government entities to purchase locally made food and products: http://bit.ly/1dG8XX4
Michigan: HB 4487 would amend an economic development statute to include the creation and funding of programs to promote local agriculture: http://1.usa.gov/1oDBkH5
Mississippi: HB 1556 would provide a state income tax credit to grocers that amounts to 25 percent of the cost of purchasing locally grown and produced products starting in 2014: http://bit.ly/OaTaWq
Missouri: HB 2088 would create a “Farm-to-School Program” within the department of agriculture to help facilitate the use of locally grown produce in school meal programs through a website and database that would link farmers and schools. The bill, which was introduced March 5, sets up a task force that is charged with developing recommendations for the program: http://on.mo.gov/1fij1SA
New Jersey: SR 44 calls on state and local government entities to purchase locally made food and products: http://bit.ly/1dG8XX4
Rhode Island: H7494 would create a task force for developing recommendations on how to improve the nutrition of food sold at state facilities, including promoting locally grown products: http://bit.ly/1fwAA0W
Lest we forget, the Center for Responsive Politics produced these statistics on farm bill lobbying:
- 325. Number of companies and organizations registered as lobbyists in 2013 to work on the Senate’s farm bill through the end of October 2013 — the fifth-most of any legislation
- 111.5 million. Amount “agribusiness” spent on lobbying in the same period, more than even the defense industry and labor unions.
- 93 million. Amount companies and individuals in agriculture made about in campaign donations during the 2012 presidential campaign.
If we want the next farm bill to promote fruits and vegetables (a.k.a. specialty crops), we need to start working on it right now.